While you may love the convenience of soft, spreadable butter, that benchtop block belongs in the fridge, says Pepe Saya founder Pierre ‘Pepe’ Issa.

It’s the most common questions he’s asked at his Carriageworks market stand and cultured butter factory in Tempe and Caringbah.

“I came from one of those households where they would leave the butter out on the table for days and days. But in our house now? Never. We never leave it out. Ever,” Pepe says emphatically.

While it’s not uncommon to see butter bells on kitchen counters, Pepe says this is primarily a European tradition and not one that is not compatible with the Australian climate.

“If you lived in Norway you could probably get away with it as the temperatures don’t really get high enough to cause it to stink or melt, but in Australia, you can only leave it out for around 2-3 days in summer and 5-7 days in winter. After that, it’s gone,” Pepe says.

“If you can’t consume a whole block of butter in that time then it needs to be kept in the fridge.”

It’s also worth noting that cultured (unhomogenised) butter, like that made by Pepe Saya, tends to go off quicker than the homogenised blocks found in the supermarket aisles.

While it’s unlikely, there also the chance that butter left out may become contaminated by a secondary source, such as a dirty utensil.

“If a harmful pathogen like E. coli or listeria finds its way into the butter, it will also multiply at a much quicker rate,” says Pepe.

Essentially, butter will last longer and stay safer in the fridge, plus it’s also more likely to keep its good taste.

For those who like the texture of soft butter, Pepe says cultured butter is naturally more spreadable than homogenised butter, and only needs to be out of the fridge for a few minutes before it starts to get soft.

If you need to keep butter out of the fridge for an extended period of time, like for a camping trip, plant-based butter is a safer bet than dairy-based butter.

“I’ll admit, there’s also an element of preference to it,” says Pepe. “I really like my butter hard. In our house we slice it down and put it on the bread like a piece of cheese.”

Related news: Can’t find the butter for the clutter? Here are 29 foods that don’t belong in the fridge